The recent and laughable account by Xinbo Wang, Bo Zhang and David Zhigang Wang in JACS that sodium hydride is an oxidant has been challenged by an online cabal of chemists over at TotallySynthetic. It was further questioned at CBC and has been the scorn of folk in the office.
I almost feel compelled to do the reaction, but from the comments section it seems pretty clear: in the absence of oxygen, sodium hydride does not an oxidant make.
It’s a pretty tough reality and a stinging rebuke that people can essentially do basement chemistry and have your shit debunked before it even makes it into print. This is the nature of the blogosphere, the inernets and the future.
Of course, there was no scandal here… it was a bit sensational. Peer review triumphed again, even if it happened only after the publication (or has it not been published yet? See… this online shit is confuckingfusing).
UPDATE: Missed it. Do this in a glove box and it doesn’t work. Open it up to air and you get 80% yield. All apologies to those involved..
» Behind door number 6 is phlogiston
06/12/13 07:50 from Chemistry Blog
Nick is still churning out cracking chemistry limericks for advent. Hope you are enjoying them. Phlogiston When trying to explain combustion, Alchemists had a conjunction, The theory decreed, For fire you need, A material contain...
» WIRED Space Photo of the Day: Curiosity’s 100,000th Shot
05/12/13 19:23 from Wired Science
Since landing on Mars in August 2012, NASA's Curiosity Mars rover has fired the laser on its Chemistry and Camera (ChemCam) instrument more than 100,000 times at rock and soil targets up to about 23 feet (7 meters) away. This ... ...
» Parkinson's From the Environment?
05/12/13 16:53 from In the Pipeline
I've been meaning to link to this piece by Lauren Wolf in C&E News on the connections between Parkinson's disease and environmental exposure to mitochondrial toxins. (PDF version available here ). Links between environmental toxins and d...
» Drug Companies In Great Britain: Ease Up, Won't You?
05/12/13 15:01 from In the Pipeline
The tension between drug companies and regulatory agencies is constant. It would be there even if no one cared a bit what drugs cost, because you can talk about safety and efficacy without ever mentioning a price. But since we do care ab...
» Bugs and Spiders Disguised as Poop, Leaves, and Each Other
05/12/13 11:30 from Wired Science
Insects and spiders are masters of disguise, easily hiding in plain sight while pretending to be plants, dung, or one another.
» Chemical limericks for advent. 5th December:
05/12/13 08:36 from Chemistry Blog
Don’t drop nitroglycerine! A pyromaniac sealed his fate When nitroglycerine did detonate A flask dropped to the floor He was no more Due to its shockingly sensitive state. By Nicholas Dawson
» Cassini Captures Amazing High-Res Animation of Saturn’s Mysterious Hexagon
04/12/13 21:05 from Wired Science
NASA's Cassini mission has captured an incredible high-resolution animation of the psychedelic jet stream known as Saturn's Northern Hexagon.
» WIRED Space Photo of the Day: Youngest X-Ray Binary
04/12/13 19:27 from Wired Science
The youngest member of an important class of objects called X-ray binaries has been found using data from Chandra (blue) and the Australia Compact Telescope Array (purple). X-ray binaries consist of a dense object -- either a black hole ...
» The Old AstraZeneca Charnwood Site
04/12/13 16:10 from In the Pipeline
Trying to find tenants for the former AstraZeneca campus at Charnwood. A few buildings are being demolished to make room, and they're hoping for biomedical researchers to move in. I hope that works; it seems like a good research site. I'...
» More Vaccine Fearmongering
04/12/13 14:58 from In the Pipeline
Seth Mnookin's The Panic Virus is an excellent overview of the vaccine/autism arguments that raged for many years (and rage still in the heads of the ignorant - sorry, it's gotten to the point where there's no reason to spare anyone's fe...
» Visit National Parks on Other Planets With These Fantastic Posters
04/12/13 14:30 from Wired Science
Come see the ice geysers of Enceladus, the searing volcanoes of Io, or the secluded canyons of Mars! The wonders of the solar system have never looked so wonderful. That’s the sense you get from looking at this brilliant collection of .....
» Cancer Cell Line Assays: You Won't Like Hearing This
04/12/13 11:39 from In the Pipeline
Here's some work that gets right to the heart of modern drug discovery: how are we supposed to deal with the variety of patients we're trying to treat? And the variety in the diseases themselves? And how does that correlate with our mode...
» The Window: Piecing Together a Power Plant With Salt, the Sun, and 10,000 Mirrors
04/12/13 11:30 from Wired Science
Outside Tonopah, Nevada, a construction team of 600 is working to get the Crescent Dunes Solar Energy project up and running by 2014. WIRED has an exclusive look inside the construction of this first-of-its-kind renewable-energy power pl...
» Volcano Alert: A System to Warn Us About the Next Major Iceland Eruption
04/12/13 11:30 from Wired Science
Remember how Iceland's Eyjafjallajökull volcano shut down air traffic over the continent in 2010? A team of 100 scientists is working on getting ahead of the next major eruption.
» Chemical Limericks for Advent 4: DNA
04/12/13 08:04 from Chemistry Blog
The structure we all know today, To be that of DNA, Watson and Crick’s Double Helix, Deduced by Franklin’s diffracting X-rays, The discovery was a great occasion, For those of Darwinian persuasion, Crick and Watson recorded, ...
» WIRED Space Photo of the Day: Titan and Vortex
03/12/13 19:33 from Wired Science
The sunlit edge of Titan's south polar vortex stands out distinctly against the darkness of the moon's unilluminated hazy atmosphere. The Cassini spacecraft images of the vortex led scientists to conclude that its clouds form at a much h...
» Science Gifts: Running Experiments at Home
03/12/13 17:01 from In the Pipeline
Interesting science-gift ideas can be found in the "home experiments" area. There's been a small boom in this sort of book in recent years, which I think is a good thing all the way around. I believe that there's a good audience out ther...
» What You Can Publish After a Shamectomy
03/12/13 16:49 from In the Pipeline
The sleazy scientific publishing racket continues to plumb new depths in its well-provisioned submarine. Now comes word of "Stringer Open" - nope, not Springer Open, that one's a real publisher of real journals. This outfit is Stringer ,...
» Wormholes and Quantum Entanglement May Be Linked
03/12/13 16:02 from Wired Science
Theoretical physicists have forged a connection between the concept of entanglement — a mysterious quantum mechanical connection between two widely separated particles — and that of a wormhole, a hypothetical connection between black hol...
» Merck's Drug Development in The New Yorker
03/12/13 12:16 from In the Pipeline
The New Yorker has an article about Merck's discovery and development of suvorexant , their orexin inhibitor for insomnia. It also goes into the (not completely reassuring) history of zolpidem (known under the brand name of Ambien), whic...
» How to Treat Depression When Psychiatrists Are Scarce
03/12/13 11:30 from Wired Science
Psychiatrist Vikram Patel has a radical idea to make mental health counseling available to people in developing countries: train ordinary people in the basics of psychotherapy.
» Chemical Limericks for Advent 3: Charles goodyear, RUBBER!
03/12/13 06:47 from Chemistry Blog
When rubber started to be used In tires and tubing and shoes In the cold it would shatter, in the heat it would splatter And abrase when hardly abused Charles Goodyear by chance would discover A way to strengthen his rubber When into...
» WIRED Space Photo of the Day: Polar Ring Galaxy
02/12/13 19:17 from Wired Science
This new Hubble image shows a peculiar galaxy known as NGC 660, located around 45 million light-years away from us. NGC 660 is classified as a "polar ring galaxy", meaning that it has a belt of gas and stars around ... &nbs...
» The Truth About ISON: What Happened to the Comet Over Thanksgiving?
02/12/13 18:53 from Wired Science
It's dead! It's alive! Did something survive? Here is the final truth on what happened with comet ISON over the last few days.
» Authorship For Sale. Papers For Sale. Everything For Sale.
02/12/13 15:12 from In the Pipeline
Academic publishing fraud in China has come up here before , but Science has an in-depth look at the problem. And a big problem it is: "There are some authors who don't have much use for their papers after they're published, and they can...
» Eisai Cuts Back
02/12/13 14:17 from In the Pipeline
Getting the week off to a bad start is this news from Eisai. They're stopping small-molecule work at their site in Andover, and (like everyone else, it seems) chopping med-chem at their UK site as well. Worldwide, it looks like a loss of...
» Chemical rhymes for Advent 2: The discovery of phosphorous
02/12/13 06:41 from Chemistry Blog
Before chemistry really evolved Alchemists tried to make gold They mixed stuff together To find out whether It’d form enough gold to behold In the seventeenth century An alchemist boiled up his wee It stared to spark and glow in the dark...
» Aspiring Graduate Students: You have questions, Mike Shatruk has answers!
01/12/13 17:03 from Chemistry Blog
Are you thinking about applying to a chemistry graduate program? Do you have a few questions first? What is the application process? What items do I need to gather in order to apply? What is the most important part of my application pack...
» WIRED Space Photo of the Day: Jupiter From Mars
01/12/13 11:30 from Wired Science
The HiRISE camera is the most powerful telescope to have left Earth orbit. As such, it is capable of some interesting astronomical observations. This image of Jupiter and its major satellites was acquired to calibrate the pointing and co...